|
Great Glass
Michael H Schulst - Man Magnum Magazine September 1999
In my youth I prided myself on the acuity of my vision, but indelibly etched
in my mind is the memory of the first time that I ever looked through a pair of
binoculars. It was in the Kamberg area and my father and an old man called Bob
Rawlinson had been glassing the upper reaches of the Little Mooi River one late
summer's afternoon when old Bob handed me the binoculars which he told me had
been taken from a German U-boat during the last war. Looking through those
binoculars made a deep impression on me, and engendered a life-long interest in
optics.
In retrospect, I can't recall, during the four decades or so that have passed
since then, any binoculars impressing me as much, irrespective of price,
superior optics or more modern design. There are several reasons for this.
Firstly, I was a kid and the experience was absolutely novel. Secondly, the air
was crystal clear and the viewing conditions ideal as the beautiful greens of
the weeping willows contrasted perfectly with the dark blue river and the deep
shades of brown on its banks.
Further, the binoculars were most probably marine 7x50s which categorizes
them as 'night glasses', and as I was very young my pupils had more than likely
dilated in the fading light to a diameter in excess of 5mm, so I was able to
make full use of the large exit pupil diameter and high twilight performance of
the old Zeiss glasses. To borrow some advertising blurb from one of the major
manufacturers, it was literally as if somebody had 'turned on the lights'.
The exit pupil is the little circle of light that you will see in the ocular
lens if you hold the binoculars at arm's length, and its diameter is determined
by dividing the diameter of the objective lens in millimetres by the
magnification of the binocular. When young, your pupil is capable of dilating to
7 or 8mm, but once you have reached the age of about fifty it is incapable of
dilating to a diameter larger than about 5mm. However, when optics cannot be
held steady, such as after exertion, it is beneficial to have optics with a
larger exit pupil diameter than the dilated pupil of your eye, as the image is
then not momentarily lost through shaking as would happen if both diameters were
equal. A good rule of thumb for those with unsteady hands is to use optics with
exit pupil diameters at least 2mm greater than the maximum diameter of the
dilated pupil.
Until about five years ago I invariably recommended that one should purchase
the most expensive binoculars that one can afford as it is likely to be a
lifetime investment and the higher the price the better the quality. Well, in
the past there were some terrible examples of 'cheapies' guaranteed only to give
you headaches, but the situation has since changed somewhat and binoculars are
now available that are not only reasonably priced but have really good optics.
This is a result of computerized lens grinding techniques and far more stringent
standards stipulated by the lens industries and governments alike. Minimum
standards are now on par with those of the medium price binoculars of
yesteryear.
With today's Rand value, I categorize low cost binoculars as those priced
from say, R600 to around R1000, medium priced from R1000 to around the R3000
mark and expensive upwards of about R4000. Don't get me wrong however - you
still most definitely get what you pay for, but the difference in lens sharpness
is not as noticeable as it was in the past, and the price disparity lies in
features such as quality of construction, waterproofing, gas filling, internal
focussing, superior lens coatings, etc.
I have just spent two months evaluating a selection of Lynx binoculars. I
found them so good that I decided to alter my normal method of assessment when I
realized that the optical systems of today have largely overcome the problems of
vignetting (shadowy corners or periphery), chromatic aberration (colour
distortion) and coma (optical distortion, where rounds or circles appear oval).
I thus evaluated the binoculars according to my perception of a user's
requirements in a particular price category.
For example, I am of the opinion that the least expensive Lynx of those
tested, namely the aspheric lensed Series Eleven binocular, is at least
optically on a par with Bob Rawlinson's old Zeiss, particularly with regard to
resolving power and brightness, and let's face it , those old Zeiss binos were
very, very good. In other words, does the occasional hunter, birder or sport
watcher require a more sophisticated glass?
The test binoculars range in power from a modest 7x for the bushveld hunter
to a 10x for the open plains hunter, stargazer or birder. Two 8x were included
as I still firmly believe that this is the best all-purpose magnification for
someone wanting one pair only. I began with the least expensive, a 10x50 Lynx
Series Eleven 'aspheric' lensed porro prism binocular with a recommended retail
price of R1188 inclusive of VAT. It is usually in the lower-priced binoculars
that optical imperfections are more prevalent, and I chose a 10-power because
the higher the magnification the easier it is to detect these. I don't know very
much about the technical aspects of aspheric lenses other than that they are
half elliptical in shape and are used in the secondary mirrors of catadioptic
(mirror)telescopes. Zeiss use two such surfaces in their 30-power mirror
telescope, the idea being that edge-to-edge sharpness is improved while
production costs are contained.
During the test period Mars was particularly bright so I used these Series
Elevens to do a bit of stargazing. Colour integrity, lens sharpness and image
brightness - enhanced by little mirrors covering certain surfaces of the BaK 4
(very high grade) prisms - proved excellent, with edge to edge sharpness beyond
reproach. Only stars visible at the very outer edge of the lens displayed any
sign of coma. Field of view is given as 6.5 degrees. A binocular with a narrow
field of view gives you the impression that you are looking through a tunnel and
this can prove difficult to use in bushveld conditions or even for watching a
game of rugby. Zoom lenses generally have this problem, which is one of the
reasons why I am not very partial to them. Excessively wide fields of view, on
the other hand, are more prone to image distortion and prolonged viewing can
cause headaches.
Binoculars should be user friendly, and through the years I've found that,
irrespective of power; the field of view should be just wide enough to encompass
the four main stars forming the Southern Cross. This makes it about right for
locating game in bushveld conditions.
I am pleased to report that all the Lynx binoculars selected for this test,
including the high powered 10x50s, passed the 'Southern Cross comfort test' so I
won't mention this aspect again. Covered in attractive grey rubber the Series
Elevens sport multicoated objective and ocular lenses, a tripod socket and are
water-resistant or splash proof. They have a very wide range of focus adjustment
for those with poor vision and who prefer to use binoculars without their
spectacles, but as they are only of semi-long eye relief, only about 80% of the
field of view is visible through spectacles. On the downside, I found them to be
bulky with a height of 182mm, a width of 183mm and weighing 910g. Also, when
glassing towards bright lights, internal reflections are noticeable and,
possibly due to their superior edge-to-edge performance, they tend to distort
images while panning. These are also available in 8x40 and 7x35 versions which
are more compact. I consider these aspheric lensed Series Eleven binoculars to
be an ideal entry-level glass for the occasional viewer who nevertheless demands
a very high standard of optical excellence. In the powerful but hefty 10x50
version they are highly recommended for the 'armchair' birdwatcher, game viewer
or stargazer. Without a doubt an exceptionally good buy.
Next up on the price list is Lynx's top-of-the-range porro prism binocular,
which proved to be my favourite. Known as the Series Nineteen this glass has all
the features of the Series Eleven but in a strong, compact, brushed aluminium
body which is waterproof to a depth of a metre, implying that to prevent scratch
damage, dust can be rinsed off the lenses under a gentle stream of tap water.
The test glass was an 8x42 with an overall height of only 140mm, a mass of 690g
and a suggested retail price of R2,052 incl. All internal lens-to-air surfaces
are fully coated, and the objective and ocular lenses have no less than five
layers of hardened, scratch- resistant fluoride coatings. To enhance brightness,
mirrors are once again positioned over certain surfaces of the BaK 4 prisms and,
in combination with the lens coatings, result in what I unreservedly rate as one
of the brightest pairs of binoculars available, irrespective of price.
Bad experiences can live with you for life, and I well remember losing the
opportunity to bag the biggest bushbuck ram ever afforded me. It was high up in
the mountainous regions near Bulwer when the sun was low and to the front of the
ram. He was clearly visible to the naked eye, but as I peered through the scope
all I could see were internal reflections of the setting sun. The scope was
medium-priced with fairly sharp optics but this incident certainly taught me a
lesson about the importance of good lens coatings. Well, these fine Series
Nineteen binoculars certainly have excellent lens coatings and in this regard I
must reiterate that they are as good as any that I've ever tested. They also
feature a tripod socket and with folded eyecups, spectacle wearers enjoy a full
field of view. They are also available in 10-power in the same compact
dimensions for those who prefer higher magnification.
Binoculars, like rifle cartridges, are designed to meet specific performance
needs and the next test is of a compact roof-prismed model designed specifically
to comply with military specifications. Known as the Series 90 Military 728,
they are lightweight, compact and extremely rugged. Military binoculars must be
waterproof and shockproof and objects must be quickly located with steady images
even after vigorous exercise or under stressful conditions. In order to achieve
this the magnification is 7x power with an exit pupil diameter of 4mm. Retailing
at R2,359 incl, it goes without saying that the fully coated optics are
excellent but a feature that I found particularly endearing are the rubber
eyecups which are folded simply by pushing against them with the palm of the
hand, and once folded, afford a full field of view to spectacle wearers. Lynx
would do well to use similar eyecups on other models in their range. With
compact dimensions, they fit into a hunting shirt pocket and weigh only 425g.
These military binoculars are protected by green camo rubber armour, hence won't
make a noise if they bump against your rifle, and come supplied in a matching
canvas carry case with strong steel clasps for secure attachment to a hunting
belt.
Focusing is of the individual eyepieces with positive click stop adjustments
for pre-setting for particular hunting conditions, permitting rapid refocusing
from, for example, infinity to intermediate settings. An optional feature
included in the above price is a graticule for distance estimation which should
appeal to the bowhunter. Waterproof to 2m and capable of withstanding vibration
and drop tests onto concrete, these are the choice of men who spend time hunting
in harsh conditions where light weight and compact dimensions are of more
importance than quick focussing and high magnification.
Finally, Lynx's top of the range' roof-prismed Series 40, incorporating the
very latest design features such as lenses housed within a one-piece cast alloy
body and full internal focusing, ensuring perfect sealing against air or
moisture being sucked into the housing by the backward and forward motion of the
focusing lenses. They are also purged with nitrogen to prevent internal fogging
if quickly taken from a warm to a cold environment. The eyecups are retractable
so that after extended use they do not become worn and unsightly. Optically
these Series 40s are exceptionally sharp and reading tests showed them to be the
best in the range, although possibly not quite as bright as the Series
Nineteens.
The convenient focusing control is butter-smooth in operation but I did not
particularly care for the positioning of the right eye diopter adjuster (for
individual eye focus) which tended to upset the focus of the central focusing
control during setting. This problem is overcome simply by using a fingertip of
the left hand to prevent the central focusing control from turning.
Spend some time practicing this both at night (at distant lights) and during
the day and memorize the average setting for optimum performance for your eye.
Weighing 895g these are not light, though they are reasonably compact with
height, depth and width dimensions of 149 x 110 x 73mm respectively and are the
same whether of 7, 8 or 10 power All glass-to-air surfaces are multi-coated with
the result that colour rendition and internal reflection control is outstanding.
Waterproof to a depth of 2m, these binoculars not only incorporate the finest of
optics and features that one would expect from the top of the range product but
they also look extremely elegant.
I also liked the wide and comfortable carry strap with a quick detachable
rain-guard, and I would like to see Lynx replace the skimpy little straps
supplied with the other models with this far more substantial version. Highly
recommended for the serious birder or ornithologist, and for anyone who
regularly uses binoculars and demands ruggedness with outstanding optical
performance in a reasonably compact package. You only have to examine the design
integrity and feel the heft of the Series 40 to realize that this is a glass
designed to last a lifetime, and with a suggested retail price of R4,788 I would
have expected Lynx to offer a 20-year guarantee, rather than five as for the
rest of their product range. Last but not least, Lynx boast one of the best
equipped workshops in the country with technicians capable of repairs ranging
from replacement of the rubber armor to lens collimations and this is highly
reassuring when considering a purchase. |